She's referring to this book(which I need to read), and the piece is about history of conflict:
There probably is some bias in there (and not on the side of white anything) though I don’t remember detecting it, when I did my deep dive into African history 17 years ago. What became very clear to me is that whenever civilized (in this case defined as post-tribal) humans collide with tribal humans, tribal humans lose. They use the techniques that work in between tribes, imagining that their adversaries are also a tribe:
They start off with unimaginable massacres and horrible evil in the belief that this will cause the adversaries to back off. Because this works, between tribes. But when you’re dealing with people who view human individuals as both important, and important regardless of tribe, the more atrocities they commit the more they aggravate the anger of the civilized people.
The civilized hold back, afraid of committing atrocities, and the tribal humans commit more atrocities, and act like victors, while doing truly horrific things.
And then at some point the post-tribal people lose it.
What comes after is usually horrific and causes college majors to cry centuries later.
This dance has been performed over and over and over again, since Rome at least. Since we had a polity that transcended tribes. The end is always the same.
So, the neo-tribal barbarians of the left who are following the script to the letter might wish to hear and revise their tactics. They won’t, of course, but we should warn them, all the same. Since we’re the ones who are trying to avoid the horrors.
2 comments:
The Washing of the Spears is a wonderful book, very well researched. It gives flesh to the near mythical story of Rorke's Drift, and understanding of the players on both sides.
Her thesis about Tribal vs Post-Tribal people is spot-on. I witnessed this first hand in Iraq. The pattern she describes holds true and is scalable. Large or small there is a fundamental misunderstanding between the two that neither side seems able to bridge.
Instead of "Washing The Spear", it is cleaning the bore. Works for me...
Post a Comment